New Sun-Times Lit Editor Savored a Whiskey Whose Name She Misspells

Posted by Anneli Rufus at 10:03 am, Friday, June 23, 2006

Sam Jones at Goldenrulejones.com links to a Chicago Sun-Times article in which that paper’s new literary editor introduces herself. In “A Book Lover’s Approach to Her New Job,” Cheryl Reed tells us that after devouring a biography of Simone de Beauvoir, she felt “as if I had lost a wise, old friend. In my grief, I drove to a liquor store and, though at age 24 I was not a Scotch drinker, I bought a bottle of Johnny Walker Red because that’s what Simone drank. The bottle was expensive for a young journalist, and I had the clerk wrap it in red paper to further celebrate my extravagance. Then, in the privacy of my studio apartment, I held my own memorial for a great author, toasting the person whose determination to be a writer had so inspired me.” Okay. So if she spent thaaaat much time reading about this fine liquid, buying a bottle, watching it being wrapped, and doing a ritual with it at home, and if she’s a journalist, how could she manage not to notice that the proper spelling of its name is not “Johnny” Walker but Johnnie Walker. (Or did she spell it right originally and some wily copyeditor messed with her?) This kind of error will not inspire Chicago-area readers with confidence. Nor will this grotesque sentence, later in the article: “With slick advertising, vague book titles and artfully designed jackets, clever marketing has propelled mediocre books to the best sellers lists.” Best sellers lists? Reed reassures her readers: “You’ll also notice a greater focus on women writers and books that appeal to female readers…. Don’t worry. We’re not forgetting books that men enjoy. There will still be plenty of reviews on books about sports and business.” Ummm — imagine what would happen if a male literary editor announced, “We’ll still review books that ladies like: cookbooks, for example, and books on shopping and doing your hair.” Reed adds: “But there will be even more on biographies and nonfiction titles.” Umm … reviews on books, not of them? Weird! Or is it some kind of Midwestern slang?



8 Responses to “New Sun-Times Lit Editor Savored a Whiskey Whose Name She Misspells

  1. Sam Says:


    Visit Sam

    You make some good points, Dibsy. What really bugged me was:

    “And professional book reviewers sometimes write with such literary references, as if the reader has a master’s degree in 19th century literature. What’s a reader to do?”

    I don’t know. Maybe, god forbid, learn something?

  2. Danny Says:


    Visit Danny

    Once again, I find myself laughing my ass off at one of your posts. This is priceless. Thanks!

  3. Edward Champion’s Return of the Reluctant » Roundup Says:


    Visit Edward Champion’s Return of the Reluctant » Roundup

    [...] I agree with Dibs that a book review editor who misspells Johnnie Walker is highly suspect. Particularly for those of us out here in literary land fond of liquor. [...]

  4. JawwermaDew Says:


    Visit JawwermaDew

    Because these assignments were originally made in the second decade of the 20th century, they often reflect a former political structure that has long since ceased to exist. For example, t
    he V series (as in Victoria) originally was reserved for the British Empire, though Great Britain itself was assigned all of B, G, and M; individual subseries of V were carved out and assigned to individual dominions and territories.
    expresso.awesomewebspace.com

  5. Pal pay phentermine. Says:


    Visit Pal pay phentermine.

    Phentermine without a prescription….

    Phentermine….

  6. Effects of long term percocet use. Says:


    Visit Effects of long term percocet use.

    Can percocet cause nightmares….

    Neo percocet. Percocet online….

  7. hiecumedild Says:


    Visit hiecumedild

    What is bumburbia?

  8. Renae Naze Says:


    Visit Renae Naze

    I’ve no time for people who eat like pigs and then try to find magic pills, diets and programs. When you eat a lot of, you will end up fat no mater what. And i am not especially slim but I do jog and feel healthy, without feeling hungry all the time. Get a grip folks!


Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>